Monday, May 4, 2015

MMGM: Winter Cottage



MMGM: Winter Cottage


This is an oldie, but goodie. It was first published in 1939, and I heard it about it recently on a “best books for kids” list. It wasn’t just the time period—although I love the 30s—but it was the premise--about a family living in an abandoned summer cottage—that stole my heart.

It is a classic, but one I had never heard of.

The synopsis (from Goodreads):

A family that is down on its luck during the Depression appropriates a summer cottage in the Wisconsin woods, where they spend the winter and welcome all visitors, including a runaway youth and two strangers. How Pops and his two daughters cope with their misfortunes without losing heart is a very entertaining story.

That doesn’t do it justice, so here is the book flap:

It is the fall of 1930, the beginning of the great depression. Thirteen-year-old Minty Sparkes is already aware that she has a large responsibility for her family’s well being, for although she loves her poetry-quoting father, both he and she realize that his verses and charm will not feed or house them and Eggs, Minty’s younger sister.

How the Sparkes family manage during this penniless winter—and the unusual experiences they have—make a story that young girls will read with understanding, sympathy, and delight. A double-surprise ending adds to the reader’s pleasure, and the handsome drawings by Fermin Rocker capture the feeling of the characters and local.

Ignore “young girls.” I think this is a book that would appeal to all.

What I loved:

A flawed parent who endearing. I supposed it’s because I am a parent myself, but I have a hard time reading MGs where the parent is despicable. Pop is shiftless and not very practical, but he loves his kids. And what’s not to love about a guy who makes prize-winning pancakes and quotes poetry?

A simpler time. Like reading Little House on the Prairie, this book reminds you of a simpler time, when kids made their own fun and when in dire straits, people made do. This was refreshing to read and a good reminder that although economic times have been hard for our country in recently, they are nothing to the Great Depression.

A platonic friendship. I really enjoyed Joe Boyles, a runaway, who joins them at the cottage. He and responsible Minty immediately hit it off, but throughout the book, it never goes beyond a good friendship. This was a refreshing change from most of the middle grades I read.

Premise. I loved the inherent conflict in Dad wanting to stay at someone else’s cottage and promising to pay “when his ship came in” along with Minty’s feelings of responsibility. You can’t help but feel for Minty and her dad. I also thought the book dealt with the ethical question of this in a very relatable way for kids.

Interesting twist ending. The author did a great job of giving of false leads so that I was pleasantly surprised at the ending—though I had guessed one of them. 

If you have a craving for a trip back to yesteryear or the 30s, check this out. Kids who like gentle reads with description and sweet endings would love it.

As I was reading, I couldn’t help but think of the modern equivalent, THE PENDERWICKS, which I featured last week. I had read Jeanne Birdsall say that she wrote the PENDERWICKS, because she wanted to write a book like the ones she loved as a child. I wonder if WINTER COTTAGE was one of her favorites.

Have you enjoyed any children’s classics lately?

If you're looking for Marvelous Middle Grade suggestions, check out Shannon Messenger's blog.


11 comments:

  1. Sounds like a fantastic story. And the time period is so interesting and filled with people struggling to survive but coming through it all.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Love the cover- made me want to jump right in. Sounds like the story would do the same. Thanks for featuring a title new to me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Fortunately our hard times are nothing like the Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When I saw the cover, my mind jumped to Caddie Woodlawn, another Little House-like novel by this author. If it's anything like Caddie Woodlawn, I'm in! Thanks for the review :).

    ~Paige

    ReplyDelete
  5. Caddie Woodlawn was one of my favorite books as a child, but I had never heard of Winter Cottage. I was able to find a copy at my library, so have it on order. Thanks for telling me about it. I think I will see what else Brink wrote that I haven't read.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Jenni, I love your book recs. I have not read many American classics having grown up in India so I'm continually discovering them. Right now I'm reading a bunch of books in verse, all new ... Loving the change of pace.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I adored Caddie Woodlawn but, like others above, I had never heard of this book. It sounds lovely. I was actually thinking of The Penderwicks before I read your last paragraphs. As for children's classics I've read recently, I re-read both Carry On, Mr. Bowditch and Harriett the Spy a few months ago when it was still winter here and I didn't make it to the library for new books! Both held up surprisingly well.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I love her name! Minty Sparkes. So neat. Though the first time I read it, I read Minty Sparkles. Ha!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'll admit, I'm not a huge fan of history. But when I was assigned this book to read in school, I figured that I would give it a shot. I wasn't disappointed. Thanks for reminding me! :-)

    ~Cindy

    ~Cindy

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm running a day late, as an editing job needed a fast turnaround yesterday, but I'm glad I stopped by anyway. I loved your last recommendation (The Penderwicks) and plan to spotlight it soon, so the comparison here makes me think this one needs to go high on the list, as well.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I like this one too, especially for re-read on a hot day in summer....too close to home this past winter!

    ReplyDelete