I’ve been reviewing a lot of girl books lately, but today I have one that will appeal to boys or perhaps boys and girls. It appealed to me.
I picked this up because as I said in this post, I like to read what’s already out there in my genre before I start writing. As I’m drafting a middle grade boy book and this book had some similarities to mine, I had to check it out.
Here’s the synopsis:
A statue; a coin; an old book. They look as dusty as everything else in the Faulkner Antiquarian Bookstore, where 14-year-old Sam Faulkner seeks his father, who's been missing for days. But when Sam slips the coin into the statue, he's swept back in time -- to Scotland in 800 A.D. -- where he must find both the statue and another coin in order to return to the present. It's the first step in an adventure that will take him to ancient Egypt, World War I, even Dracula's castle -- and a mystery that will end only when Sam saves his father, or loses him in time . . .
By the way, this is a book that was written in French initially, so this is a translation.
What I loved:
--Third person narration. It seems like it’s becoming rarer to find books, MG or YA, written in third person. I thought this was a great choice for this book. The focus was on the action, not introspection, but still Sam’s personality came through.
--Sam was a very likable and relatable narrator. His difficulties with Monk, a bully, and his family, especially his aunt’s boyfriend, made him sympathetic. It was fun to discover with him what time period he was in and watch him adapt.
--I loved how that his time travel adventures didn’t go as planned. He’d think—I’ll try this to get to Dad—but then it wouldn’t work and he’d have to try something else. Notes from Dad and mysterious Latin inscriptions were highlights for me!
--His relationship with his girl cousin, who helps him in the modern times, was well-done.
--I loved the whole concept of a “Book of Time”—that wherever Sam or his dad travels, information about that place shows up in a book.
My only quibble was that at the beginning of the book, it seemed like he jumped from time period to time period with no apparent purpose. I would get attached to characters in one time period, only to have him leave. Once he got to Egypt, what he learns there impacts everything else. So just stick with it! I really enjoyed the ending and how the author tied up loose ends, but left room for a sequel.
I would class as upper middle grade, especially since the age of the protagonist is on the verge of high school. There's some violence in the historical time periods. I think older readers (junior high age) would relate to Sam's modern-day issues with bullying, girls, and family.
I would class as upper middle grade, especially since the age of the protagonist is on the verge of high school. There's some violence in the historical time periods. I think older readers (junior high age) would relate to Sam's modern-day issues with bullying, girls, and family.
If you like time travel, history, and adventure, this is the book for you.
This is the first in a series. There is also: Gate of Days and The Circle of Gold.
To check out more Marvelous Middle Grade suggestions, check out Shannon Messenger's blog.
This is the first in a series. There is also: Gate of Days and The Circle of Gold.
To check out more Marvelous Middle Grade suggestions, check out Shannon Messenger's blog.
This is good timing for me as I've been searching for some good third person MG stories. Thanks for the interesting background on this book.
ReplyDeleteI'm so glad you found this helpful! It's so hard to find good 3rd person stories, especially since so much is written in 1st. Hope you enjoy it!
DeleteSounds like a good one! I like MG aimed at the upper readers in the bracket. There are many readers not ready for YA and its topics but who need more challenging topics than provided in younger MG.
ReplyDeleteYes, I agree--I think this would be perfect for those types of kids. I hope you enjoy it!
DeleteI hadn't heard of this one. Thanks for the recommendation!
ReplyDeleteI don't think I would've found it either if I wasn't looking for something set in Scotland. Hope you enjoy!
DeleteI read this book years ago, but I'd actually forgotten about it. Thanks for the reminder. I remember the same frustration at the jumps in time.
ReplyDeleteYes, I actually put it down for awhile, because of the time jumps, but then I was so glad I picked it up again. :)
DeleteAs a history lover, this sounds right up my alley! I appreciate the recommend, and also the heads up to be patient with the time jumping in the beginning. It's nice to know when a book is going to pull itself together and is worth sticking it out. Thanks, and happy MMGM!
ReplyDelete--Suzanne
www.suzannewarr.com
Yes, I'm a history lover, too. I especially loved the parts in Iona and Bruges (1400), although you might like other bits, depending on your favorite era. Happy MMGM to you too!
DeleteThis sounds very intriguing, thanks for sharing it. I love time travel in history.
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by, Pam! I'm a big time travel fan too. Hope you enjoy it!
DeleteI'm a sucker for time travel and this idea of a book of time is a new one, very intriguing...and of course I can't resist anything that has to do with special books. Books are under-appreciated characters for as many book lovers as there are! :)
ReplyDeleteI so agree! I love it when a book is a character or a force of its own--enjoy!
Delete